PDF Ebook Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler
Be the very first to download this book Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler as well as allow read by finish. It is extremely simple to read this book Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler due to the fact that you don't have to bring this published Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler everywhere. Your soft data e-book could be in our device or computer so you can take pleasure in reading all over as well as whenever if needed. This is why lots varieties of people also check out the books Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler in soft fie by downloading and install the e-book. So, be just one of them that take all advantages of reviewing the book Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler by on the internet or on your soft data system.
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler
PDF Ebook Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler
Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler. A work may obligate you to consistently enrich the expertise and also encounter. When you have no sufficient time to enhance it straight, you can obtain the experience and also knowledge from checking out guide. As everyone understands, book Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler is popular as the window to open up the globe. It suggests that checking out publication Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler will give you a new method to locate every little thing that you need. As the book that we will provide below, Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler
When visiting take the encounter or thoughts types others, publication Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler can be a great resource. It's true. You could read this Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler as the source that can be downloaded and install here. The method to download and install is additionally very easy. You can visit the web link page that our company offer then buy the book making a bargain. Download Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler and you can deposit in your very own tool.
Downloading guide Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler in this web site lists could provide you a lot more benefits. It will reveal you the best book collections as well as completed compilations. So many publications can be discovered in this internet site. So, this is not only this Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler Nevertheless, this book is referred to read since it is an impressive book to provide you more opportunity to obtain experiences and ideas. This is simple, check out the soft file of guide Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler as well as you get it.
Your perception of this book Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler will lead you to obtain what you precisely require. As one of the impressive publications, this publication will certainly provide the visibility of this leaded Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler to gather. Even it is juts soft documents; it can be your cumulative file in gadget and other gadget. The crucial is that use this soft documents publication Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler to check out and take the perks. It is exactly what we suggest as book Awash In A Sea Of Faith: Christianizing The American People (Studies In Cultural History), By Jon Butler will certainly improve your thoughts and also mind. After that, reading publication will also enhance your life quality much better by taking great activity in well balanced.
Challenging the formidable tradition that places early New England Puritanism at the center of the American religious experience, Yale historian Jon Butler offers a new interpretation of three hundred years of religious and cultural development. Butler stresses the instability of religion in Europe where state churches battled dissenters, magic, and astonishingly low church participation. He charts the transfer of these difficulties to America, including the failure of Puritan religious models, and describes the surprising advance of religious commitment there between 1700 and 1865. Through the assertion of authority and coercion, a remarkable sacralization of the prerevolutionary countryside, advancing religious pluralism, the folklorization of magic, and an eclectic, syncretistic emphasis on supernatural interventionism, including miracles, America emerged after 1800 as an extraordinary spiritual hothouse that far eclipsed the Puritan achievement―even as secularism triumphed in Europe.
Awash in a Sea of Faith ranges from popular piety to magic, from anxious revolutionary war chaplains to the cool rationalism of James Madison, from divining rods and seer stones to Anglican and Unitarian elites, and from Virginia Anglican occultists and Presbyterians raised from the dead to Jonathan Edwards, Joseph Smith, and Abraham Lincoln. Butler deftly comes to terms with conventional themes such as Puritanism, witchcraft, religion and revolution, revivalism, millenarianism, and Mormonism. His elucidation of Christianity’s powerful role in shaping slavery and of a subsequent African spiritual “holocaust,” with its ironic result in African Christianization, is an especially fresh and incisive account.
Awash in a Sea of Faith reveals the proliferation of American religious expression―not its decline―and stresses the creative tensions between pulpit and pew across three hundred years of social maturation. Striking in its breadth and deeply rooted in primary sources, this seminal book recasts the landscape of American religious and cultural history.
- Sales Rank: #446097 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Harvard University Press
- Published on: 1992-02-01
- Released on: 1992-03-02
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.25" h x .94" w x 6.13" l, 1.20 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 376 pages
Features
- Used Book in Good Condition
From Library Journal
Butler's fine scholarly summary of the first three centuries of Christian experience in America is both well researched and very readable. Butler ranges widely, showing how the elitist Christianity of early modern Europe co-existed with belief in magic and the occult and also discussing 18th-century church establishment in America, the negligible impact of the Great Awakening, the impact of the American Revolution on religion, and the democratization of 19th-century American religion. While many of his theses are arguable, they are all impressively defended. Recommended for large public and academic libraries.
- Susan A. Stussy, St. Norbert Coll., De Pere, Wis.
Copyright 1989 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
Throughout, the richness of detail, nuance, and illustration is superb and often eye-opening...In all, it is a daring work of synthesis...meticulously researched...This book ranks among the most challenging and far-ranging historical analyses of religion in America to date. (Leigh Eric Schmidt Journal of Church and State)
This is one of those rare books that historians await impatiently for years. It is also one of those rare and remarkable books that prove worth the wait. It fulfills extravagantly the promise of those pathbreaking and pugnacious articles that made magic an essential reality of the seventeenth century and the Great Awakening an interpretive fiction of the eighteenth. It is, by far, the best account we have of early American religious life, and the most radiantly original. (Michael Zuckerman Journal of the Early Republic)
Anyone who wants to know about religion in America up to the Civil War would do well to read Jon Butler's rich, comprehensive and--it must be said--contentious account. (David Martin Times Literary Supplement)
About the Author
Jon Butler is William Robertson Coe Professor of American Studies and History, and Professor of Religious Studies, at Yale University.
Most helpful customer reviews
45 of 56 people found the following review helpful.
A Non Traditional Approach to American Religious History
By Dennis R. Hidalgo
Awash in a Sea of Faith is a book of its time. The intellectual and historiographical context of Jon Butler's revisionist history of religion in America is found in the camp that Jack Greene, Keith Thomas and David Hall have been preparing for some time now. This trend, which Butler perfects, is marked by a strong skepticism toward the influence of Puritanism in American culture, toward the major claims of American Protestantism, toward the basic dogmas of traditional American religious history and by a desire for historical and geographical egalitarianism. A pervasive skepticism is not the only component at the foundation of Butler's approach. His historical logic is partially guided by a continuous dialectic between the sacred and secular, elite and popular, the barren colonial landscape and the rise of sacred structures, orthodoxy and occultism. Considering the large and long religious historiographies in North America, Butler's approach starts with profoundly untraditional premises and assumptions. It should not surprise us, then, that Butler would arrive to untraditional conclusions. After all that is what revisionism is- to change the way we perceive history and to challenge some rusty assumptions. His main argument, that the Christianization of America came through a process of syncretism, would have not only alarmed Protestant leaders in the 19th century, but would also have worried religious historians in the 20th century. In his presentation of European Protestantism and its journey toward the America continent, Butler emphasizes occultism as a transforming force in religion and society. In doing this, he ignores the strength of the anti-idolatry Protestant movements that "cleaned out" many churches, the close relation between modern empiricism and Protestantism with its emphasis on the "Biblical evidence," and the influence of effective preaching on parishioners.
Considering that the word "holocaust" in the post World Wars is related with the Nazi's massacre of the Jews, Butler demonizes American Protestantism for its missionary zeal and for its emphasis on civil obedience among the African Americans. By doing this, Butler completely disregards the humanitarian impulse in their behalf, which was equally syncretic. And by assuming that African American ideology was secular before 1760 he contradicts his conclusion that "Slavery's destruction of African religious systems in America . . . . constituted cultural robbery. . . . of the most vicious sort." If we still ignore this contradiction, his analysis of the African-American mass movement into Protestant Christianity cannot explain how would the unsophisticated African religious systems could have been a match to Protestantism and to the complex life in American Slavery.
In revising the Great Awakenings Butler take luster out of these movements by emphasizing its conservatism and downplaying its egalitarianism. But here Butler's assumption falters in logic. He presumes that increase social status for the clergy and increment in church authority always meant conservatism. In the American religious context, where pluralism was the main characteristic, more leveled status to clergy, and more authority to non-state-churches (dissidents) meant egalitarianism- particularly compared with the European religious experience. Furthermore, by indicating that itinerant ministers opposed settled ministers selectively, he is not only ignoring their significance, but is also ignoring social forces that would naturally motivate the Itinerants to seek support and sympathy from some settled ministers while ignoring others. Curiously, Butler's analysis of American revivalism is distinguished by a robust defense to the Anglican Church, and a downplaying of dissent's strength and growth-, which is also a revision in traditional American religious history.
Throughout his entire book, but especially on the Antebellum Christianity, Butler always defines the practice of Alchemy, the curiosity for the gothic and the secret, and the believing in dreams and miracles as indication of spiritualism and witchcraft. Defining these religious experiences, which some orthodox leaders, have seen with suspicious eyes, may belie Butler's position of standardization-a secularized Protestant mainstream. At this point the reader would wonder why Butler includes the practice of alchemy with the believing in miracles, since science (to mention only two) was not as clearly define and not as evenly spread as it was a century later, and miracles have always been regarded as part of Christian beliefs. It may be that Butler needs this combination to highlight his point of Protestants' lack of purity and imprecision, which would have been impossible otherwise. Perhaps inexactitude is inbuilt in certain aspects of the study since Christianity is itself syncretic, thus invalidating any model of Christianity detached from "its" culture and historical setting.
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful.
A Different Perspective on Religion in Early America
By Craig Stephans
Butler provides a historical view of American religion that attaches less importance to Puritanism as the major force in shaping the nation's religion. He emphasizes the influence of the role of authoritarian and coercive religious practices that established and advanced religious causes in America. Additionally, Butler follows the emergence of a religious eclecticism throughout the colonies. The movement of religious influence was confluential with political and economic developments to shape the colonies. The state-church religion that primarily shaped 17th and 18th century colonial America held power based on its coercion, territoriality and public ceremonialism. He asserts that the religion of the colonists originated primarily in Europe and is incomprehensible apart from understanding its European influences. Paradoxically, Butler writes that the most enduring patterns of American religion were also created and not merely inherited.
Butler's chapters make the points that religious practice was not an organic evolution in the colonies. The governments were actively involved in dictating religious practices of their citizens. Dissenting beliefs and behavior were not welcome to the early colonies with the exception of Rhode Island and Pennsylvania which adopted more lenient libertine laws concerning religion. Religious practice was not standard throughout the colonies nor was it universal among the residents of the colonies. Butler also elaborates on the presence of magic and the occult in the New World of North America. Christians were militant against non-Christian spirituality, occult or magic. These were deemed to occur through diabolical means and were treated as such by the young governments and were later dismissed by children of the Enlightenment.
Butler's treatment of religion and slavery reveals the contradicting tension between the doctrines of Christianity and the practice of slavery. Religion was central to the argument for or against slavery. The practices of religion in the slaveholding colonies had to deal with whether to evangelize and educate the slaves and then whether to allow whites and blacks to worship together. Butler discusses the ways that whites manipulated the Scriptures to accommodate slavery. He illustrates the effect that the slavery argument had on compromising the Christian integrity of churches, as they defended and facilitated slavery
American revivalism was not a single denominational movement that sparked Christianity in the colonies. It was but another stream of religion besides the state church tradition of the establishmentarian Anglican and Congregationalists traditions. The American Revolution brought a shift in the religious landscape as Anglican ministers who supported the crown fled and as a new patriotism competed with religion or merged with it. Following the Revolution, American church leaders renewed efforts to stamp Christian values on a new independent society as a priority for the success of the infant republic.
The religious laws in Virginia illustrate Butler's thesis that religion in the colonies was initially a government sponsored institution. This is not the religious freedom one usually associates with the New World. In the 1670's it was the church-state alliance that provided the stability and authority of the Anglican Church in Virginia. The Virginia Assembly mandated Anglican churches in every county and dictated the processes for vestry elections and taxation on behalf of the church. As a result, Anglican churches, benefiting from compulsory taxes, accounted for every one of the colony's new churches constructed between 1680 and 1720.
What also becomes apparent in Butler's writing is that it was the Deist language of the Declaration of Independence that laid the foundation of religious freedom in the United States rather than the influence of the various Christian movements. It was the secular Revolution and not the religious ties of the colonists that bound the colonies together. Butler argues against historians' claims that evangelicalism was behind the sentiments and boldness behind the revolution. He claims that the Declaration of Independence provides clear-cut evidence of the secondary and supportive role that religion and Christianity played in creating and solidifying the revolutionary struggle.
In the latter chapters of his book, Butler describes the religious movements that largely resemble what we see in the United States today. Following the American Revolution, the acts of the new country allowed for religious freedom and expression. This freedom from coercion and establishment led to new denominations and even new religions like Unitarianism and Mormonism springing up.
Butler points out a new syncretism between popular supernaturalism and Christianity. The interest in spiritualism and desire for supernatural experience led to the popularity of groups like the Swedenborgs, Freemasons, Mesmerists and other spiritualists. Butler highlights four institutional expressions of the religious climate of the new country. These were Methodism, Mormonism, Afro-American Christianity and spiritualism. Butler asserts that region, class and race all constrained the religious tendencies of Americans.
Butler also asserts that denominations gained adherents through coercion and authority. He suggests that denominations "manipulated" systems of denominational meetings to further establish power and influence. Denominations shaped evangelization and the development of new congregations, often through the use of the itinerant preacher. According to Butler, denominations used books and publications to influence and expand authority.
Butler also points to a plethora of reform societies and mostly Christian colleges as contributing to the influence of religion on the society. He assigns a coercive nature to the reform societies that also used print publication to gain audiences and influence. According to Butler, immigrants and indigenous groups contributed greatly to the religious pluralism of the country. This change along with religious renewal, revival and schism brought forth hosts of new groups and new worshippers to the landscape.
For Butler, coercion is the main ingredient of American religious tradition. He seems to think the Christian history is void of God-initiated or lay-initiated growth. This might seem a harsh assessment of his perspective, but I conclude that it is only the censored spiritual movements like occult, voodoo, African rituals and natural theology that Butler thinks are "grass-root" developments. Actual growth of Christianity is due to institutional-hierarchical manipulation and coercion. Even his treatment of the development of Black churches is clouded by Butler's assertion that these were havens of African pagan-ritual as much as Christianity. The expansion of Christianity westward seems to be deemed nothing better than an entrepreneurial movement to claim new markets; the idea of the Christian desire for evangelization for the sake of saving the lost seems foreign to Butler's historical assessment. His concluding treatment of Abraham Lincoln is indicative of his worldview revealed in this book. Lincoln could not possibly have been a sincere Christian; after all, look at what he said here or there.
Butler's book does open a new window to the religious history of American. I think he fails to look into the heart of Christianity in general but sees it from the outside and judges it according to his own worldview and inclinations. His willingness to assess the history from a view other than the normal chronological path is helpful to see the patterns of religious growth and transformations. His book definitely provides me with a more elucidated perspective of our pluralistic landscape today.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
Butler Brings Relief From the Puritan Stranglehold
By Matt Tippens
Jon Butler's Awash in a Sea of Faith turns many portions of both George M. Marsden's "Jonathan Edwards: A Life" and Perry Miller's "Errand Into the Wilderness" upside down. Instead of placing Puritanism at the center of American civilization, as both Marsden and Miller do, Butler claims that Puritanism was only one part of a complex American religious landscape. Butler also finds that American Christianity did not begin with the Puritans of New England or Virginia settlers, but rather it began in the eighteenth century and was peaking by the time of the Civil War. Butler challenges the conventional interpretations of America's religious history and gives his readers cause to reconsider what has generally been accepted.
Butler begins by describing the religious heritage that colonists brought with them from Europe. A low level of Christian understanding and practice characterized Europe. This religious apathy was then transferred to colonial America and the development of Christianity was a slow process. The Virginia and Maryland colonies experienced a lack of religious participation and in Puritan New England, Butler points out, by the 1680s the decline in church membership was real not imaginary. This is not to say that religion was nowhere to be found in colonial America, but rather colonists turned to other forms of practice. Butler treats magic and the occult seriously, using witchcraft, magic, and astrology to reveal the extent and importance of non-Christian belief in America, even though it was prohibited by law. Therefore, Butler examines a component of American religion that is frequently ignored by the mainstream, Christian only, historiography.
According to Butler, American society and religion underwent enormous change between 1680 and 1760. The state church tradition, led by Anglicans, reasserted authority to such a degree that Butler contends this period marked the beginning of American Christianity. It was visible through a surge in church construction, and dissenter established elaborate denominational institutions. Here, Butler departs from the accepted prominence of New Puritanism and transfers it to the Church of England resurgence in Virginia and elsewhere. At the same time, Butler explains, enslaved Africans were having their religious practices destroyed. The only religious alternative for slaves, therefore, was to turn to Christianity. Even though their systems were destroyed, slaves kept individual practices alive and a collective Christianity began to emerge among slaves that became more Afro-American after 1800 than it was before. Here, Butler really challenges general assumptions. As white Americans turned back to the Church of England for inspiration, slaves turned back to Africa. Butler also links the rise of slave ownership with the development of Christianity and shows how the two impacted one another. Butler shows how English Anglicans shaped the slaveholding ethic, emphasizing black obedience and white paternalism, which became important for rationalizing slavery in America.
Butler views the American Revolution as a secular event. Soldiers showed little enthusiasm for religion and indifference was common in the camps. After independence, church and denominational leaders renewed efforts to make the United States a Christian nation. This involved an attack on Deism that was "suspiciously commonplace among the new nation's political and social leaders" (p. 218). As a result, by 1800 American Christianity was expanding as it never had before. Butler explains the rise of religious pluralism by looking at Methodists, Mormons, Afro-American Christianity, and spiritualism. Religion became more voluntary. By the time of the Civil War, America was becoming a "spiritual hothouse" according to Butler, with a variety of religious traditions taking hold.
By departing from the Puritan domination in America's religious history, Butler brings relief from the Puritan stranglehold. There are advantages to this. Butler steps away from Jonathan Edwards and Ralph Waldo Emerson and gives voice to others that have been overlooked in Puritan-centered studies; such as slave narratives. Butler compares the number of churches and churchgoers and finds that the Puritans were in the minority. Butler also shows that religion continued to grow in American even after the Puritans had departed from the scene. On the other hand, there are disadvantages to this approach. Even though Puritans were in the minority, they left a formal written theology that served to influence generations that followed. The new nation borrowed ideas from the Puritans. Butler, by comparing the rise of slave ownership with that of Christianity, makes a dangerous analogy. Did Christianity cause racism or were American Christians racists? It seems that racism had other origins besides religion. Nevertheless, Butler has given us reason to look outside of Puritan culture to the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries to help explain America's religious history.
See all 9 customer reviews...
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler PDF
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler EPub
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler Doc
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler iBooks
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler rtf
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler Mobipocket
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler Kindle
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler PDF
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler PDF
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler PDF
Awash in a Sea of Faith: Christianizing the American People (Studies in Cultural History), by Jon Butler PDF
